
By Lindsay Zoladz
This summer I’m working at a program at my university that teaches communications courses to high school students. Last Saturday night, the good folks at AFI were kind enough to give us passes to attend the screening of American Teen at their Silverdocs festival. American Teen was one of the most talked-about darlings of Sundance this year, and it’s getting ready for a relatively wide release. Needless to say, those of us involved in scheduling events for the students were all pretty pumped to see it. The kids, however, were skeptical.
When I went to pick them up at the dorm, one of the students glared at me and said, “This is going to be one of those movies that is like, ‘all teens are really destructive and terrible,’ isn’t it?” Sniffing out the air of dissent, a few others chimed in. “I watched the trailer online. It looks stupid.” I tried my best to quell a mutiny that seemed almost inevitable, as Kung Fu Panda had opened only a day before. “Well, we already bought the tickets,” I shrugged. Somehow, that worked. We were off, but nobody seemed too happy about it.
We arrived just on time to the AFI Silver Theater (hands down my favorite place to see a movie in the entire DC area), which stands like a glowing beacon in a turbid sea of Red Lobster and Panera that is “downtown” Silver Spring, Maryland. The kids began to let their guards down a bit, impressed by the size of the theater and swept up in the hubbub of SilverDocs. But they really came full cirlce once the film started. I could tell immediately that they were into it; they laughed at all the jokes and booed almost any time Megan, the spoiled prom queen archetype, appeared on screen. (At one point, when Megan was fretting about how her SAT scores had only gone up 70 points, one of our kids yelled out, “Oh, your life is so hard.” I mean, we were all thinking it.)
American Teen is being advertised with a poster that cleverly apes The Breakfast Club, even using the same tagline as John Hughes’ iconic ode to teen-dom. It’s an incredibly smart ad campaign, because it deflects the film’s biggest criticism up front. American Teen isn’t breaking any new ground, and it doesn’t pretend for a second that it is. It’s just one more take on an age that has always fascinated filmmakers, only this time it is seen through the lens of text messages and Facebook profiles. And although the methods might be different (the bullying of the John Hughes era certainly did not know the particular sting of having your nude photos passed around the internet), the cataclysmic feelings of teenage love, aspiration and heartbreak are all too familiar.
I’ll admit that I, like the kids, was a little apprehensive about the film at first too. After all, in a culture saturated with reality TV, the premise of the film seems pretty banal. I expected it to be a glorified episode of MTV’s Made. And in some ways, it is. In the end, American Teen doesn’t really come to any conclusions on life that are any grander than the scope of its small town high school world. But it doesn’t need to. Director Nanette Burstein engrosses you so completely in the world of these kids that you cannot even believe that there could be something out there more heart-poundingly glorious than being asked out by Mitch or more catastrophic than waiting in vain for him to call you back.
Everybody in the group was, like myself, totally swept up in the film. So much so that when one of its subjects, Hannah Bailey (the one that the ad campaign has fashioned into the Ally Sheedy of the bunch), turned out to be the surprise guest in the audience and went up to do a Q & A after the screening, we were acting a little bit like she was a bona fide movie star.
On the Metro ride home, I turned to our standard method of evaluating the evening’s activity: the gladiator-style thumbs up or thumbs down. To my pleasant surprise, I was met with twelve hearty thumbs up, and one that was pensively teetering at at 45-degree angle between up and halfway-up. I considered this a tremendous success. The only universal complaint was that the kids said they’d seen the “small town” angle pulled so many times and would have liked to seen the same story in a more urban environment. Still, in the discussion that the film generated, we were all able to agree on one simple truth: it is never Ok to break up with someone via text message. Thanks, American Teen.